Midnight X-Men #2 looks to continue the momentum created by the strong debut from the creative team of Jonathan Hickman and Matteo Della Fonte. There was a lot of world building done as the idea of Empyries was established. The way they utilized classic X-Men elements to shape this new universe where we have mutants that have been turned into vampires was intriguing. Now it is up to the second issue to solidify what was established in the debut. Let’s see if that is done with Midnight X-Men #2.
CREATIVE TEAM
Writer: Jonathan Hickman
Artist: Matteo Della Fonte
Colorist: Arthur Hesli
Letterer: Cory Petit
MIDNIGHT X-MEN #2 SOLICITATION
“Eat. Prey. Love.” – Marvel Comics
REVIEW
Midnight X-Men #2 takes a step back from showing us the entire Marvel Midnight Universe. That is not a bad thing at all as it was done on purpose to make the overall direction of the series bigger in the long run. This issue in particular helped to expand the methods the Empyres go and how Cyclops role as a thrall changes the narrative direction of the series moving forward.
When we saw Cyclops in the first issue he seemed to be a rogue X-Men with unclear motivations of what side he was on. Midnight X-Men #2 works to clarify this and uses that clarification to make sure there is no mistake Empyres are evil. It almost becomes a tragic story for Cyclops as rather than becoming an Empyre along with Jean Grey and other X-Men his love is used against him.
It is in twisting Scott Summers and Jean Grey love that we see the true horrifying aspects of the Empyres. It is not just enough that they are vampires with powerful mutant powers. In this world we got to a point where the X-Men history was what we know it to be for most characters. We get that from Jean being Phoenix and a mix of specific X-Men rosters from different eras. Having this character history means that Cyclops likely won’t be the only major Thrall we will see. The Empyres have the ability to make others like Cyclops as their numbers grow.

The whole story makes Cyclops a tragic character. Because at first you do feel sorry for him that his love for Jean is being manipulated in this way. Especially when you see how Jean and Storm purposely made sure not to turn Cyclops into an Empyre has he is more useful as a Thrall. At the same time, the deeper we get into this backstory you do find it hard to still hope he figures out a way out of being a Thrall. You get to the point that he does need to be stopped, leading to his present-day appearance having so much more weight.
This is where the strength of Jonathan Hickman’s world building shines. Because we don’t really know who to be behind. There is a feeling that this is a world of antagonists. The true protagonist will likely not show itself until we get deeper into the story. That makes for a much more compelling reading experience as we have Storm, Cyclops, Phoenix, and Dracula so heavily featured so far.
Matteo Della Fonte artwork does a very good job at telling the story of this early period in the Midnight X-Men history. Fonte utilizes the classic costumes to help make this feel like it is happening at an early point. It makes the story more tragic because as an X-Men fan you have a sense of history with these characters even though we are two issues into this universe. It also helps to make the older present day appearances mean something more than just being a darker version of these characters.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Jonathan Hickman and Matteo Della Fonte tap into fan nostalgia to create a compelling look back at the history of the universe in Marvel Midnight #2. The details about what happened to many of the classic X-Men we know leave you with feeling that the Empyres are even more dangerous. This is emphasized with the tragic role Cyclops is serving in this universe. His role and what we learn about this universe leaves us in a spot where the story could go anywhere.
Story Rating: 8 Night Girls out of 10
Art Rating: 8 Night Girls out of 10
Overall Rating: 8 Night Girls out of 10
For more opinions on anime, comic book, movies, and sports you can follow Kevin on TikTok, Bluesky, Instagram, Threads, and Twitter/X.
